New Site: Ishmael.org

DQ on Facebook!

FIND OUT ABOUT
What's new
Daniel Quinn
Daniel Quinn's books
Schools & courses
Telephone Conferences
This website
New Tribal Ventures
Ishmael's Annex
Speaking Invitations


THINGS TO DO
Register
Visit Guestbook
Find others
Help us
Order books
Contact us
Telephone Conferences
Special Requests

THINGS TO READ
Essays
Speeches
Dialogues
Parables
Answers to Questions
DQ's suggested reading
DQ's Blog

FOR TEACHERS
The Ishmael Companion
Beyond Civilization
 Study Guide


HOME

  The Ishmael Community: Questions and Answers

Related Q&A(s): 149 258 407 415 421 426 468 493 526 529 531 540 544 549 551 552

The Question...

ID: 468
posted: 23 Apr 2000
updated: 02 Apr 2002

In Ishmael you state the Takers dependence on prophets. The Lakota had a prophet, White Buffalo Calf Woman. She gave the Lakota "laws" to live by. How about the Cheyenne, who have Sweet Medicine, he was a prophet. So how can I argue with people who say that the Leavers had prophets as well as the Takers?

What Ishmael says is as follows: "What makes it so striking is the fact that there is absolutely nothing like this among the Leavers—UNLESS IT OCCURS AS A RESPONSE TO SOME DEVASTATING CONTACT WITH TAKER CULTURE, as in the case of Wovoka and the Ghost Dance or John Frumm and the Cargo Cults of the South Pacific. Aside from these, there is no tradition whatever of prophets rising up among the Leavers to straighten out their lives and give them new sets of laws or principles to live by." I've never read of ANY Leaver people who NEEDED to have their lives "straightened out"--until contact with us made it impossible for them to follow their traditional ways. Only the sick need doctors.


category: Here's My Opinion, What's Yours?,I Have a Question On a Specific Subject
keywords: Prophets,Religion,Tribal (tribe)

Related Q&A(s): 149 258 407 415 421 426 468 493 526 529 531 540 544 549 551 552


Go Back OR return to the Questions & Answers OR Browse to the Next Question
Site design and content © 2019, Daniel Quinn
Ishmael Privacy Policy