
Home
Find Out About
DQ and Rennie
DQ's books
Translations
"What to do? What to do?"
New Tribal Ventures
Video tapes
This website
Rights and Permissions
Upcoming events
Recent events
Things To Do
Buy signed Quinn books
Invite DQ
Read guestbook
Buy Ish in Bulk
Sign guestbook
Search guestbook
Buy a book
Link to us!
Spread the Word
Find a Local Group
Join the network
Make connections
Help/Sponsor us
Contact us
Visit NTV market
Things To Read
News and Info
Q & A
Science of Ish
Interviews and ...
Parables
Essays and ...
DQ's book list
Network book list
Privacy policy
Reviews of DQ's Work
For Teachers
Schools
Courses
Ish teacher guide
BC study guide
"The people of your culture imagine that the treasury was completely empty when you came along and began to build civilization ten thousand years ago. You imagine that the first three million years of human life brought nothing of value to the store of human knowledge but fire and stone tools. In fact, however, you began by emptying the treasury of its most precious elements. You wanted to start with nothing and invent it all, and you did. Unfortunately, aside from the products (which work very well), you've been able to invent very little that works well--for people."My Ishmael
|
|
|
New book from Daniel Quinn! If They Give You Lined Paper, Write Sideways
"One of the most troublesome questions I've been asked--and it's been asked hundreds of times--is: 'Where do these strange ideas of yours come from?' In the beginning, I thought it was just the usual where-do-you-get-your-ideas? question that all authors receive. My readers soon set me straight. Read more ... |
|
Excerpt 1
Excerpt 2
Excerpt 3
|
|
|
 |
Check out the News and Information Announcements...
|
Another experiment in hierarchalism · A systemic problem · Beyond hierarchalism · A wrong direction: "giving up" things
Take this as a premise. You are a member of the Honored class of the Natchez. Two of your grandparents are Suns and two are Stinkards. Your father is a Stinkard and your mother is a Noble. You yourself will marry a Stinkard. Write a paper explaining how you feel about this system as it applies to you. Does it seem fair, unfair, tolerable, intolerable?
It seems like the "systemic problem" of the Natchez could have been solved or alleviated by combining the Honored class and the Stinkard class into one. Why might the Natchez have resisted such a solution?
Quinn says "the rest of us just want something else [besides hierarchalism]." Why does he "want something else" if (as he said a few pages back) he likes his present life? Is he saying that this is not an all-or-nothing proposition?
Do "things like security, hope, light-heartedness, and freedom from anxiety, fear, and guilt" seem "precious" to you? More precious than air conditioning? More precious than television?
Even though kids who run away to join the circus aren't doing so to give up things, they do in fact give up some things. What do they give up and what do they get in return?
|